Guys, I gotta get some stuff off my chest, so bare with me, this may be long-written...
So yeah, I got V on release date and I share quite a number of complaints like you guys do. The fighting itself it cool (although I feel it's much more streamlines towards the "newbie crowd" Street Fighter IV did rather than feel like its own source material) but its mostly just the throw in of characters that are given no reason to even be around anymore and were just thrown in because they're "fan-base mainstays" that's bothering me. They went through the efforts to bring Hilde back, but she doesn't even show her face with Siegfried and Z.W.E.I. during story mode when dealing with Nightmare's forces. Viola [grown-up Amy] was told to have a major importance in the story, but doesn't even truly do anything to even be noted as a side character. She's just scenery, and says maybe only 2 lines of fate to Patroklos and that's the end of that. I would've liked to know more about why Z.W.E.I. has so much beef with Dumas/Nightmare as well. Anyone with a fragment of Soul Edge in them all of a sudden no longer aging (Maxi, Tira, and namely Ivy) bothers me, and Cervantes all of a sudden breaking free from Soul Edge and just suddenly finds a human body for literally no reason (just to go back to his days before Soul Edge terrorizing the sea) really irked my nerves. Hell, even the legacy characters are rather just handwaved for their importance value (Natsu [Taki doesn't come back from a mission in 2 weeks, decided to go on an entirely unrelated journey with the Asia group in response], Xiba [who literally does nothing but want food and that's it]). I think that even worse than just throwing in stuff like this is cutting characters that most likely would had offered a better reason to get involved in the story. Talim could've been a fully capable wind priestess by now to help purify Calibur at the very least instead of Ivy... (and we all know why Ivy made the damn cut. She's got three insurance policies after all...) And for Pete's sake, Zasalamel was not only original, he's flippin' immortal and his entire existence revolves around the damn swords, and we don't here so much of a peep out of him. As much as I hate Algol and know he's in V, he's in the same boat for not getting any story importance whatsoeveer. I just feel if you're gonna add/remove characters to a story driven game like Soul Calibur, especially since they're so important to the feel of the games, you should do more than just throw them around at will and give them real purpose for being around.
Now, I have a soft spot for Pyrrha (I'm a sucker for cute girls, after all, and she along with Leixia is my main when I play seriously), but I'm not gonna look past the things that I know are in her character design that makes her unappealing to anyone that isn't Japanese. She can definitely grate on cats' nervous systems with her whiny voice/lack of willpower early in story (as I can even see here in this thread, lol) but I do feel one of those is at least partly justified considering her background. They wanted to give her a reason (Patroklos) to be strong-willed and protective (and all that jive), but even before that, I think she could've at least used a tiny bit of that on herself to not look so darn meek (while still having the capability to 'kill' her assailants no less). Again, I personally don't mind her at all, but everyone else I know can't stand her, so ultimately that's something I hope they can work on in VI.
But who am I kidding? This game literally was centered around Patroklos, and honestly I hated him at first. The smug, douchebag characters always got on my bad side easily. His character development helped move him to neutral in my book though, and I will give the guy one thing for wanting to follow through on saving his sis, but that's about as far as he goes. I mean, did they really thing fans wouldn't raise eyebrows at a Greek native teenager being much better at a JAPANESE swordstyle than his own homeland (a move done just to include Setsuka in some way, shape and form without actually adding her)? That's all I gotta say on that matter.
Oh, and just for a side bit, Nightmare really is Raphael's dead body [the playable one is a spectre/ghost that's only barely able to hold his existence due to his 'undying love for Amy' and willpower alone]. Yeah... and it wasn't spoken about whatsoever in the game itself.
Other than my roster complaints, I don't mind the game itself outside of some random gameplay junk. The other issues I got I'll save for discussion at a place like Shoryuken.com or something, but I just had to get the monkey off my back. Now... I gotta get back to unlocking Creation parts...